Military Justice in Ukraine: Why Human Rights Defenders Warn Against Separate Military Courts
The debate over restoring military justice continues amid full-scale war, but the «Pryнцип» human rights center urges caution regarding the recreation of military courts and prosecutors due to risks to judicial independence.
🚨EventsPhoto: Ukrainska Pravda
Key points
- The issue of military justice is being reviewed by a Temporary Special Commission of the Parliament.
- The «Pryntsyp» human rights center opposes separate military courts due to risks of command pressure.
- Civilian courts have developed substantial experience in handling military cases during the full-scale war.
- Experts suggest introducing judicial specialization instead of recreating an obsolete military justice system.
The Debate Surrounding Military Courts and Current Realities
The issue of restoring the military justice system has returned to the spotlight of Ukrainian society and lawmakers due to the challenges of the full-scale war. A Temporary Special Commission of the Verkhovna Rada is actively reviewing initiatives to establish specialized courts, prosecution offices, and investigative bodies for military personnel. The main argument of supporters is that cases involving defenders should be handled by individuals with military experience who better understand the specifics of service.
However, the «Pryntsyp» human rights center for military personnel warns against hasty decisions. According to experts, the key criterion in any reform must remain ensuring the qualitative protection of soldiers' rights and the impartiality of justice. Judicial proceedings are traditionally based on judicial independence, whereas the military relies on command authority and strict subordination. Combining these two systems creates serious risks for the objective resolution of cases.
Why Civilian Judges Are Capable of Handling Military Cases
The primary threat of establishing military courts, experts note, is the potential influence of the command vertical. Since military ranks are awarded to judges with the participation of the Ministry of Defense or the General Staff, this opens the door to administrative pressure. Past examples of such influence include legislative initiatives like draft law No. 8271 or the General Staff's 2025 proposals to tighten penalties for certain offenses, which focused primarily on punishing subordinates rather than addressing command abuses.
Human rights defenders emphasize that the civilian judicial system has accumulated significant and qualitative practice in handling military cases throughout the war. Knowing the law is not guaranteed solely by a military rank, and when specific expertise is required, the law allows for involving professional experts. Therefore, instead of creating a cumbersome and vulnerable system of separate courts, «Pryntsyp» advocates for introducing narrow specialization among current judges for military-related offenses, fully aligning with European standards.
Source Ukrainska Pravda — pravda.com.ua/news/2026/11/20/8063800/ ↗
Read next
👥SocietyTragedy in the Maramures Mountains: Ukrainian national dies attempting to cross the border
A Ukrainian citizen has died in the Romanian Carpathians during heavy snowfall, while two others were rescued by local emergency services.
Miracle rescue: 7-year-old boy pulled from rubble in Dymer
After 14 hours buried under the ruins of an apartment building in Dymer, 7-year-old David was rescued. The child miraculously survived a Russian drone strike.
Ukraine's Energy Grid: Power Outage Schedules for November 23
On Monday, November 23, planned power outages will be implemented across Ukraine due to the aftermath of attacks on the energy infrastructure.
German Army Intends to Test Ukrainian Delta Combat Management System
The German armed forces have shown interest in the Ukrainian Delta system for potential integration, highlighting its autonomy and technological advantages.
🛡️SecurityZelenskyy announces new enemy tactic targeting energy grids across several regions
President Volodymyr Zelenskyy reported a shift in enemy attack tactics aimed at destroying power lines and cutting off key regions from energy sources.
⚽SportDenys Berinchyk Defeats Bovar Khanakov at Capital Martial Arts Tournament
Renowned Ukrainian boxer Denys Berinchyk successfully returned to the ring after a series of setbacks, defeating Bovar Khanakov in Kyiv. The bout took place under unconve…